The Heartfelt Journey of Separated Conjoined Twins

From Charlie Gard to the separation of conjoined twins, the agonizing realm of life-and-death choices plays out at the forefront of hospitals.

Dr. Joe Brierley is no stranger to the unenviable ethical dilemmas showcased in tonight’s broadcast of a new BBC documentary on Great Ormond Street Hospital; he has confronted similar situations before.

Marieme and Ndeye are two-and-a-half-year-old conjoined twins who have surpassed all medical predictions by surviving to this age. The twins share a circulatory system but have separate hearts and lungs. Ndeye’s vital organs are in good condition, while Marieme’s heart is critically compromised. Should she pass away, her more robust sister will also succumb.

As their condition deteriorates, the hospital – and their father, Ibrahima – are faced with the decision of whether or not to perform surgery to separate them: a choice that could prolong the life of one twin but almost certainly result in the loss of the other.

Dr. Brierley, a consultant in pediatric intensive care and chairman of the hospital’s ethical committee, engages in a series of dialogues with colleagues and the girls’ father to determine the best course of action. The tense deliberations resemble a verdict of life or death.

“As a father, how do you make sense of the fact that people are even thinking that way?” asks Dr. Brierley, a 50-year-old father of four children, one of whom has faced their own health complications. “If a decision like this doesn’t weigh on your mind, you’re in the wrong job.”

Great Ormond Street Hospital is a global authority in treating conjoined twins, drawing patients from all over the world. Cases like Safa and Marwa Ullah, two-year-old sisters from Harsadda, Pakistan, who underwent 50 hours of surgery to successfully separate their skulls, have made headlines.

However, conjoined twins are not the only cases that appear before the ethics committee. In the digital age, medical professionals find themselves making decisions under public scrutiny.

The case of 11-month-old Charlie Gard, who passed away in 2017 following a protracted legal dispute between his parents and Great Ormond Street Hospital over experimental therapy in the United States, is familiar. A High Court judge ruled in favor of the hospital’s argument against travel, sparking widespread criticism.

Dr. Brierley, despite confidentiality, emphasizes the complexity behind these decisions. “This is what is missing from social media: the complexity of how parents are routinely involved in this.”

The Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health recently issued guidance to help parents understand the potential impact of sharing online or involving media in their cases.

Dr. Brierley worries about the rapid spread of outrage on social media, which oversimplifies the ethical debates he faces. “There are subtleties and nuances lost.”

Great Ormond Street Hospital established a clinical ethics committee early on, addressing the complexity behind these sensitive decisions. Dr. Brierley and his team reach agreements with parents “95 percent of the time” on “a shared path from a very difficult place.”

Despite the controversies, he maintains that the proposed law by Charlie Gard’s parents isn’t necessary. “In our work with children and their families, we constantly base decisions on parental opinions.”

The case of Ndeye and Marieme, the conjoined twins, saw the decision not to operate. They remain alive, receiving care from their father and a hospice in Wales.

Dr. Brierley acknowledges the uncertainty of predicting the future. “One must always have the humility to admit, ‘I cannot predict the future.'”

Hits: 17